Pomme de Terre A Novel of the Minnesota Uprising (Audible Audio Edition) Candace Simar James Norwood Blue Cottage Agency Books
Download As PDF : Pomme de Terre A Novel of the Minnesota Uprising (Audible Audio Edition) Candace Simar James Norwood Blue Cottage Agency Books
1862 was a tumultuous year in Minnesota history. The youngest state in the Union, Minnesota was one of the first to send men to fight in the Civil War. With the men gone, women and children were left to fend for themselves. The Civil War drained soldiers formerly stationed in Minnesota military outposts, leaving the state undermanned and unprotected. Budget woes related to war expenses caused treaty payments to be very late. Indian agents at the Lower Sioux Agency refused to hand out needed supplies until the gold arrived. The Sioux were starving. The result was the Sioux Uprising of 1862, the largest Indian war in US history. Because it happened between the bloody battles of Shiloh and Antietam, it was largely unknown. Its effects on Minnesota and the Sioux Nation still reverberate today. Abercrombie Trail, the first book in the series, tells the story of Scandinavian immigrants caught up in the clash of cultures. Although the government declared the uprising over in the fall of 1862, Pomme de Terre tells the story of settlers living in the western part of the state, where raids continued through the following year.
Pomme de Terre A Novel of the Minnesota Uprising (Audible Audio Edition) Candace Simar James Norwood Blue Cottage Agency Books
I enjoyed the first book in the series, but this left a lot to be desired. First of all, the punctuation was non-existent or confused. Names changed often, I'm guessing a spell checker additions and lack of editing. E.g. Character Gust, became Gus, character Standing Tall became Standing Tail, Christmas Jul became July. Not just occasional changes, but often these happened. The story is not compelling, it's pretty obvious how it's going to end after the first farm incident. The reading of coffee grounds becomes more than a forshadowing device, to the point Aunt Karen predicts the boat, date and time when something occurs. Right. Historical accuracy is okay, but the idea of catching a steamboat in St. Cloud and riding it down to Iowa is just plain ignorant when the largest falls on the whole Mississippi, St. Anthony, lies inbetween. Also, there is little given to explain why the Dakota are so angry and desperate.Product details
|
Tags : Amazon.com: Pomme de Terre: A Novel of the Minnesota Uprising (Audible Audio Edition): Candace Simar, James Norwood, Blue Cottage Agency: Books, ,Candace Simar, James Norwood, Blue Cottage Agency,Pomme de Terre: A Novel of the Minnesota Uprising,Blue Cottage Agency,B00WA8PGF4
People also read other books :
- Thor Omnibus Books
- Shadows in Summer A Novel in Six Voices Crescent Varrone 9781439251966 Books
- The Prince Filibooks Classics Illustrated edition by Nicolo Machiavelli Filibooks W K Marriott Politics Social Sciences eBooks
- The Book of Philadelphia eBook Robert Shackleton
- North American P51D/ K Mustang and Cavalier F51D Conversion SMI Library Pawel Matysiak 9788361220879 Books
Pomme de Terre A Novel of the Minnesota Uprising (Audible Audio Edition) Candace Simar James Norwood Blue Cottage Agency Books Reviews
This book was great! I learned a lot about Minnesota history and it really held my interest. Not my usual genre, but I'm planning on reading the entire series!
Purchased the entire series after reading this book. Author gave excellent insight into the history of the settling of Minnesota during the 1860's Dakota Indian uprising, and the sad decision by President Lincoln to hang 38 Native Americans.
I enjoyed this book because it takes place in areas where I've lived. The writing (including character development) and plot could have been better, but all in all it was a good book. I'll likely read the 2nd (of 4) book, and I'll decide from there whether I'll read the others.
Since I was born and raised in Minnesota, I thought that I had a pretty good idea of the history of my home state. Not So! My grandparents immigrated from Norway about 40 years after the Sioux uprising. Because it occurred between two of the worst battles of the Civil War, Shiloh and Antietam, it has been overlooked by most history books .
I highly recommend this book and the rest of Ms. Simar's series to gain a fuller appreciation for all out immigrant grandparents and great-grandparents struggled through to give us, their descendants a better life.
I loved this book. I had read the Abercrombie Trail and loved that, too. I appreciated how it was written. I am now reading her 3rd book and will then go on to the Blooming Prairie. I enjoyed how the author ( my 2nd cousin )used the familiar names of people in our past. She did so much work to have this be as accurate as possible to inform us of how it was at that time.
Pomme de Terre, the second book of a trilogy by Candace Simar, continues to feature a war many ignored at the time--and many have conveniently ignored since. There are reasons. The primary battles of the Great Sioux Uprising in Minnesota of the 1860s occurred between battles at Shiloh and Antietam (of the Civil War). Union military and financial resources are stretched thin by a more pressing conflict. As a result, settlers receive no protection; Native Americans receive nothing to provide for their families and suffer greatly when promised provisions are not delivered.
Against this background, settlers move into unsecured territory where they live and love--surviving, making mistakes, prevailing when they can. Young Gust and Serena Gustafson and other settlers of Norwegian descent--along with the soldiers who make up the inadequate military presence--represent this culture. Of Norwegian descent herself, Simar would have multiple sources for understanding these people, and she takes the high road as a writer by creating characters who are less than perfect--including one with a fatal flaw because he cannot deal with the wounds of his childhoo.
Meanwhile, a young Native American husband and father named Drumbeater represents the second culture. For this group Simar did extensive research on the mindset of the Native Americans of the time. She describes Drumbeater's confusion when he considers the hordes of people invading his homeland--a reality prophesied by Native American seers. She depicts his sense of propriety and justice--intuitive within his background but beyond the understanding of settlers. And she portrays the delight he has in his wife and infant son--and his anguish when he cannot save them from destruction.
Within the context of the time-frame, tragedy is guaranteed. Nevertheless, I closed the book both satisfied and enriched. Pomme de Terre offers understanding of a drama created by a great people-migration. It also provides opportunity to experience intense emotions in response to the drama. This was an excellent read.
Candace Simar relates this story through at least three different viewpoints--those of Serena, a naive Norwegian girl; her husband Gust Gustafson, a young and brash Swedish pioneer; and Drumbeater, the nephew of Evan Jacobson's life-and-death Dakota friend, Crooked Lightening, who accepts the duty of delivering the captive girls Ragna and Birdie Larson safely into Evan Jacobson's hands. Candace realistically portrays the tensions of life on the western Minnesota frontier--those of the Indians who rebel when their treaty is not honored; of the settlers who are struggling to survive; and of the soldiers who are torn between the casualties of both Civil War battles and Indian uprisings. Although the story is not a particularly happy one, I enjoyed watching Serena grow and come to grips with a husband who was often selfish and less than honest. Her growth eventually results in her salvation.
I enjoyed the first book in the series, but this left a lot to be desired. First of all, the punctuation was non-existent or confused. Names changed often, I'm guessing a spell checker additions and lack of editing. E.g. Character Gust, became Gus, character Standing Tall became Standing Tail, Christmas Jul became July. Not just occasional changes, but often these happened. The story is not compelling, it's pretty obvious how it's going to end after the first farm incident. The reading of coffee grounds becomes more than a forshadowing device, to the point Aunt Karen predicts the boat, date and time when something occurs. Right. Historical accuracy is okay, but the idea of catching a steamboat in St. Cloud and riding it down to Iowa is just plain ignorant when the largest falls on the whole Mississippi, St. Anthony, lies inbetween. Also, there is little given to explain why the Dakota are so angry and desperate.
0 Response to "[VLR]≡ Read Pomme de Terre A Novel of the Minnesota Uprising (Audible Audio Edition) Candace Simar James Norwood Blue Cottage Agency Books"
Post a Comment